Keep council assets in public hands

Strong consensus: Council was united, and went against this promise. A framed marker means the member voted with that united Council. ★ made this promise.

• MemberRecordVotes in line
• Catherine Lezer
  Voted consistently againstStrong consensus
  0 of 3
  split 0 of 1
• Liam Gobbert
  Voted consistently againstStrong consensus
  0 of 4
  split 0 of 1
• Viktor Ko ★
  Voted generally againstStrong consensus
  1 of 4
  split 1 of 1

Too few votes to judge: Reynolds (1), Goncalves (1), Doshi (1)

Not yet on Council for these votes: Ma, Patton, Pacan

• 26 AUG 2025

  Colonnade Lot 104 (900) Hay Street, Perth: Property Disposal: Unsolicited BidUnanimous

  Carried 8–0. In line with the promise: a No vote.

  Why

  Approves key terms to sell the City-owned Colonnade lot, Lot 104 at 900 Hay Street, to a private buyer for $810,000 on an unsolicited bid; in line would be opposing the sale (2025-08-26 OCM minutes p.314).

  YREYBruce Reynolds voted Yes, not in lineYGONDavid Goncalves voted Yes, not in lineYLEZCatherine Lezer voted Yes, not in lineYDOSRaj Doshi voted Yes, not in lineYGOBLiam Gobbert voted Yes, not in line–MAYKOViktor Ko voted Yes, not in line–PAT–PAC

  Yes: Reynolds, Goncalves, Lezer, Doshi, Gobbert, Ko and 2 former councillors

  Not yet on Council: Ma, Patton, Pacan

• 29 AUG 2023

  Altona Laneway (Part 100 on P1419), West Perth: Property Disposal: Outcome of Local Public Notice

  Carried 4–2. In line with the promise: a No vote.

  Why

  Final approval to sell part of Altona Laneway (City-owned land, Part Lot 100 on P1419), West Perth, to a private buyer after considering 19 submissions; a vote against the disposal keeps the land in public hands (2023-08-29 OCM minutes p.820).

  –REY–GONYLEZCatherine Lezer voted Yes, not in line–DOSYGOBLiam Gobbert voted Yes, not in line–MANKOViktor Ko voted No, in line–PAT–PAC

  Yes: Lezer, Gobbert and 2 former councillors

  No (in line): Ko and 1 former councillor

  Not yet on Council: Reynolds, Goncalves, Doshi, Ma, Patton, Pacan

• 27 JUN 2023

  Altona Laneway (Part Lot 100 on P1419), West Perth: Property Disposal: Unsolicited BidUnanimous

  Carried 7–0. In line with the promise: a No vote.

  Why

  Approves key terms to sell 177 sq m of Altona Laneway (City land) to Comserv for $675,000 and authorises public notice, with the final decision returned to Council; in line would be opposing the sale (2023-06-27 OCM minutes p.431). Caveat: minor laneway parcel.

  –REY–GON·LEZ–DOSYGOBLiam Gobbert voted Yes, not in line–MAYKOViktor Ko voted Yes, not in line–PAT–PAC

  Yes: Gobbert, Ko and 5 former councillors

  Did not vote: Lezer

  Not yet on Council: Reynolds, Goncalves, Doshi, Ma, Patton, Pacan

• 27 APR 2021

  Introduction of Council Policy 2.7 Property Performance, Investment and DisposalUnanimous

  Carried 9–0. In line with the promise: a No vote.

  Why

  Lowers the bar in the new property disposal policy so unsolicited offers within 90% of market value, not only those 20% above it, go to Council, widening the route to selling City property to private buyers (p.91).

  What it changed. In point 9.1 of draft Policy 2.7, replaces 'unless the offer exceeds the Market Value of the Property by 20%' with 'unless the offer is within 90% of the Market Value of the Property'.

  Note. The amendment sets which unsolicited offers for City property go to Council for decision; it does not itself sell anything. Its printed reason was 'to lower the threshold for which unsolicited bids are considered by Council' (p91).

  –REY–GONYLEZCatherine Lezer voted Yes, not in line–DOSYGOBLiam Gobbert voted Yes, not in line–MAYKOViktor Ko voted Yes, not in line–PAT–PAC

  Yes: Lezer, Gobbert, Ko and 6 former councillors

  Not yet on Council: Reynolds, Goncalves, Doshi, Ma, Patton, Pacan